Skip to content

A Million-Pregnancy Study Just Found That Gaining Too Much Weight Raises Serious Risk — No Matter Your Starting BMI

October 23, 2026
A Million-Pregnancy Study Just Found That Gaining Too Much Weight Raises Serious Risk — No Matter Your Starting BMI

A new analysis of more than a million pregnancies in Ontario, Canada, has delivered an uncomfortable finding for expectant mothers and the doctors who counsel them: gaining too much weight during pregnancy raises the risk of severe, potentially life-threatening complications — and that risk shows up across every starting body size, from underweight to Class III obesity. The study, led by Associate Professor Laura Anderson and PhD candidate Sahar Khademioore at McMaster University, was presented at the International Congress on Obesity (ICO 2026) in Mexico City in July and has been circulating in health coverage this week as researchers push to get the message past the usual “watch your weight” framing aimed only at women who start pregnancy heavier.

The team, working as part of McMaster’s SERENE Project and funded by the Juravinski Research Institute, linked a decade of Ontario birth registry data (BORN) with hospitalization records (CIHI) covering April 2012 through March 2022. That gave them a retrospective cohort of 1,035,927 singleton pregnancies — large enough to break results down by pre-pregnancy body mass index (BMI) category and still find statistically meaningful patterns in each one.

Most women gained more than guidelines recommend

The first number that stood out: 52.8% of the women in the study gained more than the gestational weight gain (GWG) range recommended for their BMI category. Only 28.6% landed in the recommended range, and 18.6% gained too little. In other words, excessive weight gain wasn’t a minority pattern — it was what happened to the majority of pregnancies in the dataset.

Those recommended ranges, set out by the U.S. Institute of Medicine and endorsed by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, call for underweight women to gain 28–40 lb, healthy-weight women 25–35 lb, overweight women 15–25 lb, and women with obesity 11–20 lb over the course of a pregnancy. The guidelines date back to 1990 and were last updated in 2009, and researchers have long noted they aren’t consistently applied in routine prenatal care.

The complication risk cuts across every BMI group

The outcome researchers tracked was severe maternal morbidity (SMM) — a composite of potentially life-threatening events during delivery hospitalization, including major hemorrhage and sepsis. Overall, SMM occurred in about 1.46% of pregnancies, or roughly 3 in every 200. That baseline rate is already a meaningful reminder that serious complications aren’t rare outliers in modern obstetric care.

What changed the picture was comparing women who gained excessively to those who gained the recommended amount within their own BMI category. The increased risk of SMM tied to excessive gain was:

  • Underweight: 33% higher risk
  • Normal weight: 24% higher risk
  • Overweight: 16% higher risk
  • Class I obesity: 21% higher risk
  • Class II obesity: 28% higher risk
  • Class III obesity: 24% higher risk

“Healthy pregnancy weight gain isn’t just important for women with a higher BMI,” Khademioore said, summarizing the study’s central message. “We found that excessive weight gain was common and increased the risk of serious complications across all BMI categories.” Gaining too little also carried risk, particularly for women who started pregnancy at a normal or overweight BMI — but the researchers found that pattern was a weaker signal among women with obesity, where excessive gain remained the dominant concern.

Chronic conditions make the risk compound, not just add up

One of the more striking findings involved women who entered pregnancy with chronic hypertension or diabetes. A normal-weight woman with one of those conditions who also gained weight excessively had nearly three times the SMM risk of a normal-weight woman with neither risk factor who gained an appropriate amount — a jump the researchers say is larger than what simply adding the two individual risks together would predict. That suggests excessive weight gain doesn’t just stack on top of a pre-existing condition; it appears to amplify it.

The study is a conference presentation rather than a peer-reviewed published paper, and as a retrospective cohort analysis, it can show strong associations without proving that excess weight gain directly causes the complications — other factors tracked less precisely in registry data, like diet, physical activity, or access to prenatal care, could play a role too. Still, the sample size and the consistency of the pattern across BMI groups is what’s drawing attention from obstetric researchers and the World Obesity Federation, which helped publicize the findings.

What it means for prenatal care

The researchers’ ask is straightforward: more consistent counseling and support for healthy weight gain during pregnancy, regardless of where a patient starts. “This highlights the need for more resources to support healthy pregnancy weight gain,” Khademioore said. That could mean more standardized weight-gain tracking at prenatal visits, dietitian referrals built into routine care, and clearer patient-facing guidance that doesn’t treat weight gain as a concern only for women who start pregnancy at a higher BMI.

For expectant parents, the practical takeaway isn’t to chase a number on the scale alone, but to talk with an OB or midwife early about what a healthy gain range looks like for their specific starting weight — and to flag chronic conditions like hypertension or diabetes so weight gain can be monitored more closely throughout the pregnancy. Tools that make it easier to track gain against recommended ranges, discussed with a provider rather than used for self-diagnosis, were cited by several commentators on the study as a reasonable low-cost step patients can take between appointments.

A pregnancy journal or weight-tracking log that patients bring to each prenatal visit remains one of the simplest ways to keep that conversation grounded in real numbers rather than guesswork — something many OB practices already encourage. Pregnancy journals and weight trackers designed for this purpose are widely available and can make it easier to spot a gain trending outside the recommended range early enough to discuss it with a provider.

As an Amazon Associate, TrendScope Daily earns from qualifying purchases made through links in this article.