“Verity” finally hit theaters this weekend, and the numbers tell a familiar story about Hollywood’s complicated relationship with Colleen Hoover. The Amazon MGM Studios psychological thriller, starring Anne Hathaway, Dakota Johnson, and Josh Hartnett, opened on October 2 after a release date that had already been pushed back once, from a planned May debut. Industry trackers projected a domestic opening in the $25 million to $30 million range, with some estimates reaching as high as $35 million on the strength of heavy walk-up sales and a reported 17 percent share of weekend showtimes. It is, by any measure, a significant swing for a film built almost entirely on the fandom of one romance-thriller novelist.
A Long Road to the Screen
Directed by Michael Showalter, who previously worked with Hathaway on 2024’s “The Idea of You,” “Verity” is adapted from Hoover’s 2018 novel of the same name by screenwriter Nick Antosca. The plot follows Lowen Ashleigh (Johnson), a struggling writer hired to finish the remaining books in a bestselling series after its author, Verity Crawford (Hathaway), is incapacitated by a mysterious accident. While staying in the Crawford family’s home to sort through research materials, Lowen discovers what appears to be Verity’s unfinished autobiography, one that casts serious doubt on the kind of person — and mother — Verity really is.
The film carries a reported $40 million budget and runs 117 minutes. Principal photography took place in New York City between February and April of 2025, with Antosca’s screenplay going through several rounds of rewrites before it was finalized in late 2024. The shift from a May release to October is notable on its own; studios typically move genre thrillers for marketing reasons, scheduling conflicts, or simply to find cleaner air on the calendar, and Amazon MGM has not detailed its specific reasoning publicly.
Hollywood’s Hoover Problem
“Verity” is the latest entry in what has become an unofficial subgenre: the Colleen Hoover cinematic universe. Her novels have sold more than 20 million copies, propelled largely by BookTok, and studios have been racing to turn that readership into box office receipts with mixed results. “It Ends with Us,” released in 2024, remains the gold standard, opening to roughly $50 million domestically and finishing its run near $148.5 million in the United States alone. But the two adaptations that followed, “Reminders of Him” and “Regretting You,” each opened in the $13 million to $17 million range and landed at almost identical domestic ceilings of about $48 million.
That inconsistency makes “Verity” something of a bellwether. Its darker, more overtly thriller-driven premise sets it apart from the contemporary-romance tone of Hoover’s other adaptations, and early tracking suggested audiences were responding to that distinction, at least going into opening weekend. Readers who want to revisit the source material or see how closely the film sticks to the novel can find Colleen Hoover’s original “Verity” novel on Amazon, which has remained a steady backlist seller since its release.
What the Critics Actually Think
Reviews have been split. “Verity” is currently sitting at a 46 percent critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, a number that places it in the “mediocre but watchable” tier rather than the awards conversation. Several critics have singled out Hathaway’s performance as the film’s strongest asset, with some outlets going so far as to call it the most effective Hoover adaptation yet on pure craft, even while describing the overall film as uneven. The split mirrors a pattern across the genre: audiences who come in for the twisty, melodramatic plotting tend to walk away satisfied, while critics evaluating the film purely as a psychological thriller find its pacing and third-act reveals less convincing.
A Crowded Weekend at the Multiplex
“Verity” wasn’t competing in a vacuum. Four other films were tracking in the $8 million to $12 million range for second place this weekend. Tom Cruise stars in “Digger,” a political satire directed by Alejandro González Iñárritu with a reported budget north of $100 million and a 52 percent critics’ score. Brad Pitt’s survival drama “Heart of the Beast” is holding on in its second week, as is A24’s Robert Pattinson-led reality-TV thriller “Primetime.” Zach Cregger’s “Resident Evil” reboot, meanwhile, is in its third week and still pulling a respectable audience. Against that backdrop, “Verity” comfortably topped the chart, but the real story of the weekend is how fragmented the mid-tier of the box office has become, with no single film beyond the top spot clearing double digits.
Why This Weekend Matters
For Amazon MGM, a confirmed opening in the $25 million-plus range validates a strategy of leaning on built-in literary fandoms rather than original IP or established franchises, a bet that studios across the industry are watching closely as traditional franchise fatigue sets in. For Hoover, it is further proof that her backlist has become one of the more reliable pipelines in modern studio filmmaking, even if the box office ceiling for any individual adaptation remains an open question. Whether “Verity” can hold its audience through a second and third weekend, the way “It Ends with Us” did, or fade quickly like “Reminders of Him,” will say a lot about whether this particular story — rather than just the Hoover name — is what’s pulling people into theaters.
As an Amazon Associate, TrendScope earns from qualifying purchases made through links in this article.